The Raid 2

The success of the first The Raid went to Evans’s head and brought his boundless ambitions to light. These ambitions are not limited to revolutionary depictions of action, but unfortunately also include storytelling. The director has obviously watched Leone and Coppola, so instead of the striking video-game structure of the first instalment, this time he delivers a showy mafia saga in which a third of the runtime is taken up by goons and the rest of the film is importantly narrated and plotted by the bosses. The film tries to placate viewers even in the plot-development passages through emphasis on formalistic stylishness and coolness, but despite the nice images, it’s like bad porn, where the viewer merely waits for the men to shut up so they can get to the action. Though on paper these passages are supposed to add a dramatic element to the action, in practice that element is limited to kitschy pathos in the best case and, in the worst case, a ridiculously strained appendage stretching the runtime. One can now wait with interest as to whether Evans will take a different route in terms of the genre and stylistic direction of the planned third instalment, which would give the whole trilogy an element of experimentation and, mainly, retrospectively justify the choice of the style used in the second instalment. The deviations from the liveliness of the first film seems rather like the unfortunate influence of the growing co-producer, XYZ Films, whose trademark has become superficial fan-service pomposity and a calculated attempt at otherness, resulting in detachment and empty gestures. Therefore, in The Raid 2 we have comic-bookishly stylised characters with special attacks and costumes (Hammer Girl, Baseball Bat Man, Prakoso) who gush pathos and coolness from every pore, but involving them in the effort to make a tense mafia saga only exposes the whole project as a juvenile genre fantasy targeted at hipster movie fans who hide their consumerism and proneness to being manipulated behind their ostentatious rejection of the mainstream. But these are all just the aforementioned appendages or perhaps even concessions made in exchange for the freedom of implementation for the film’s main attraction. Here, a revolutionary mix of contact choreography, computer-generated effects and brilliant formalistic arrangement combines contemporary Western and Eastern action-movie trends into a thrilling whole, much like Matrix did in its day. With the bigger budget brought about by the success of the first instalment, Evans could also afford to take the action a step beyond the relatively cheap fight scenes. Whereas in the first instalment the choreography was worked out by Evans together with the lead actors, Iko Uwais and Yayan Ruhian, this time the crew included professionals from abroad, led by Hong Kong-based automotive action expert Bruce Law and fight choreographer Larnell Stovall (Undisputed III, Universal Soldier - Day of Reckoning). ___ Update after the second viewing in 2020: Though all of my criticisms still apply, nothing better has yet been made in the action genre in terms of choreography, even though the John Wick franchise gives The Raid 2 a respectable run for its money. But with its combination of physically gifted performers who know how to give and take punches, a director with a feel for action scenes and a refined style and staging ambitions, The Raid 2 has simply achieved the best balance so far. (2015-01-24) (less) (more)