Agora

The course of history sometimes takes sad directions, where in certain situations we have to wait 1,200 years to rediscover things. And yet, even after so many experiences, we are not able to think better of it and learn. This is a producer suicide and one mirror elegantly set to today’s Islam on how faith, so necessary for many, can easily be swept down a path of fanaticism that knows no bounds, nor respect. (2010-07-15)

As two hours of history, it's okay, with solidly outlined battles both physically and spiritually. As a film, however, it fails. It's only bearable for two hours thanks to the lavish production design and solid philosophy, because it's hard to sympathise with the frigid Rachel Weisz on any level other than scientific, and the other characters are elusive. In addition, there are confusing fight scenes, inconsistent emotions, and an awkward outcome. Maybe, if they had thrown in some allegorical madness or a few sad looks, I would have thought it was directed by the chief philosopher Aronofsky. (2015-06-25)

...and since they didn't beat each other up back then, they're still fighting to this day. The only difference is that stones and sticks are no longer in use and have been replaced by much more "advanced" weapons. That’s too bad. My hat is off to both Amenábar the screenwriter and Amenábar the director, for he has managed to put together a film in which I have nothing to fault. There is no need to think long about the relevance of his idea, nor is it necessary to consider whether Rachel Weisz is better looking or better acting (it's a tie, of course), I fell in love with Marianelli's soundtrack a long time ago... But I was absolutely stunned by how good Agora looks. The director intersperses breathtaking aerial shots of a living Alexandria with stunning space views of Earth, perhaps to suggest that someone is watching the mayhem going on below... If that's the case, I wonder if that someone is grinning in amusement or shaking his head and wrinkling his forehead in despair. (2011-11-19)

Quite possibly the best film by Alejandro Amenábar and a great serving of history from ancient Alexandria with the beautiful Rachel Weisz to boot. Very nicely shot, with some gritty scenes of people being stoned alive, nicely narrated, clearly told and rich in religion. There aren't many great historical films and I appreciate every one. Great. 85%. (2017-11-27)

The story is almost timeless and definitely manages to captivate, the setting is grandiose, and the actors, led by the beautiful (Miss Teacher) Rachel Weisz and the fanatical Ashraf Barhom are very good. Amenábar is good at telling stories, and despite sometimes trying too hard to manipulate situations to reflect current problems, he navigates the story with a firm hand. I really appreciated that the sub-plot was devoted to exploring the universe (thanks to that we have breathtaking footage from space) and one of the most remarkable libraries of the ancient world. (2010-07-22)